Tile Repair

Guide · Homeowners · 3 min read · Updated 17 November 2026

How to Replace a Cracked Tile Without Damaging Others

Short answer

To replace a cracked tile, rake out the grout around it, score an X across the tile and break it out from the centre with a chisel, working away from neighbouring tiles. Scrape the old adhesive flat, back-butter the new tile, press it in level with its neighbours using spacers, let it set, then grout and clean. A tiler typically charges £90–£220 for one to three tiles.

How to Replace a Cracked Tile Without Damaging Others

Before you start: find out why it cracked

A tile cracked by a dropped object is a simple replacement. A crack that runs in a straight line through several tiles, or a tile that cracks again after replacement, usually means something below is moving. Common causes include a timber floor that flexes, a crack in the screed or concrete slab beneath, tiles laid across a joint between two different materials, or no movement joint around the edge of a large floor.

Tap the surrounding tiles with the handle of a screwdriver. A crisp sound means the tile is well bonded. A hollow, dull sound means it has lost adhesion and may be next to fail. If several tiles around the cracked one sound hollow, plan to lift and refix those too rather than replacing just one.

Tools and materials

Having everything ready before you start helps, because once the tile is out you will want to finish the job without leaving an open hole in a shower wall or busy floor. Make sure the replacement tile is the same thickness as the original, otherwise it will sit proud or low.

ItemWhat it is for
Grout rake or oscillating multi-toolRemoving grout around the damaged tile
Cold chisel and club hammerBreaking out the tile from the centre
Safety glasses and glovesProtection from sharp tile fragments
Masking tapeProtecting the edges of neighbouring tiles
Wide scraper or sharp chiselFlattening old adhesive
Tile adhesive and notched trowelBedding the new tile
Spacers and spirit levelLining up the new tile with the existing ones
Grout, float and spongeFilling and finishing the joints

Step by step

Work slowly. Most damage to neighbouring tiles happens when people rush the removal stage or lever against the edges of good tiles.

  • Rake out all grout around the cracked tile down to the adhesive
  • Run masking tape along the edges of surrounding tiles to protect them
  • Score an X across the cracked tile with a tile scorer or carbide pen
  • Tap a chisel into the centre and break pieces out towards the middle
  • Scrape old adhesive back until the surface is flat and below tile depth
  • Dry fit the new tile to check it sits level and leaves even joints
  • Apply adhesive to the wall or floor and a thin layer on the tile back
  • Press the tile in with a slight twist, set spacers and check level
  • Clean adhesive out of the joints before it sets
  • Leave to set as the adhesive instructions state, then grout and wipe clean

Common mistakes

The most common mistake is not removing enough old adhesive. If the bed underneath is lumpy, the new tile sits proud of its neighbours, creating a lip that catches on a floor and looks obvious on a wall. Another is levering out pieces of the broken tile using the edge of a good tile as a pivot, which chips the glaze on the neighbour and turns a one-tile repair into a two-tile one. Use a straight edge laid across the new tile and its neighbours to check it sits flush before the adhesive starts to grab, while there is still time to adjust it.

On floors, dabbing adhesive only at the corners of the new tile leaves voids underneath. The tile sounds hollow and is likely to crack again under load. Full coverage matters, especially for porcelain and large format tiles. Finally, grout colour rarely matches perfectly. Fresh grout looks brighter than grout that has aged for years, so a full regrout or a grout colourant over the whole area may be needed for a perfect match.

Tiles behind fittings and in showers

Replacing a tile in a shower enclosure needs extra care because the area must stay watertight. If the tiles are on a waterproofed backer board or a tanking membrane, the chisel must not cut into it. A damaged membrane will let water into the wall even after the new tile is grouted. Many tilers use an oscillating tool with a fine blade here rather than a chisel and hammer, to keep control.

Tiles behind a toilet, basin pedestal or radiator may require removing the fitting first. If plumbing has to be disconnected, factor that into whether you tackle it yourself. Once grouted, a shower tile should be left for the full curing time on the grout packaging before the shower is used.

When to use a professional tiler

A tiler is worth calling if the tile is large format, natural stone or a period tile, if it sits in a shower, if several tiles sound hollow, or if the crack appears to be caused by floor movement. They can also source matching tiles and advise on whether a chip repair would be a better option than replacement.

Professional replacement of one to three cracked tiles typically costs £90–£220. That includes careful removal, adhesive, grout and cleaning, and a check of the surrounding tiles. Where the floor needs work to stop the movement, such as overboarding a springy timber floor with cement board, the tiler will explain the extra work and price it separately. Ask for photos of the finished repair and the product names used, so any future repair can match the adhesive and grout.

Questions people also ask

Can I put a new tile over a cracked one?

It is not a good idea. Tiling over a single tile makes it stand proud of its neighbours and the crack underneath may continue to move. The cracked tile should be removed and the adhesive scraped flat so the replacement sits level. For whole floors, overtiling is sometimes possible but needs a sound, well bonded base.

How long after replacing a tile can I grout it?

It depends on the adhesive. Rapid-set adhesives can often be grouted after a few hours, while standard-set adhesives usually need around 24 hours. Always follow the adhesive manufacturer's instructions. Grouting too early can disturb the tile and leave it sitting slightly out of line with its neighbours.

Why does my new tile keep cracking?

Repeated cracking almost always means something is moving below the tile. Common causes are a flexing timber floor, cracks in the screed, poor adhesive coverage or missing movement joints. The cause needs fixing first, for example by stiffening the floor or adding a decoupling membrane, before a replacement tile will last.

Written and checked by the Tile Repair team. Read our editorial policy.

Get a free tile repair quote

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a clear price.

Request a quote